Welcome
    Audit or Peer Review?




    What it is
    Who to ask for advice
    The Application Form
    End of Project Report




    What it is
    Who to ask for advice
    The Application Form
    Setting the Standard
    Setting the Sample Size
    End of Project Report     Example Audits



    Facilitators Area  

Clinical Audit - Example Audits

Four examples of completed projects are available here, to use as a guide for your own audit, or to show the type of project that is commonly done.

Radiograph Audits

This is a popular topic for a first audit.
  1. Set a standard you feel is reasonable and practical. For example - 85% of intra-oral radiographs will be clinically acceptable

  2. Define what you mean by clinically acceptable. For example:
    A bitewing radiograph is clinically acceptable if it meets 10 of the following 12 criteria:
    • Mesial 8 to distal 4 visible
    • Cusps superimposed
    • No proximal overlap
    • 3mm of crestal bone visible
    • No uneven distortion
    • No coning-off
    • Good contrast
    • Correct exposure
    • No bend or fold marks
    • No processing artefacts
    • No chemical staining
    • Correctly labelled, dated, and stored
    • Can you think of more?

  3. Draw up a similar list for periapicals, occlusals, or OPGs, if they are being included in your study. Use a separate list for each.

  4. Create data collection sheets to score your films, with a column for each criterion
    Film No 8 to 4
    visible
    Cusps
    superimposed
    No proximal
    overlap
    etc etc Total
    Score
     1            
     2            
     3            
     4            
     etc            


  5. Take around 40 of your existing films, and score them. You will find out what the common problems are, and also whether you are meeting your standard.

  6. Modify your standard (up or down) if necessary.

  7. Decide what changes you want to implement. For example, if coning off is a common problem, you may want to try a different film holding system. Or if poor contrast is common, consider a system for changing the chemicals according to how many films have gone through.

  8. Institute the changes.

  9. Take another 40 or so films, and remeasure your performance. Are the problems solved? If yes, this cycle is finished.

  10. If you are still not meeting your standard, implement more changes, and then re-measure.

  11. Once your standard is met, re-audit every so often to ensure you are maintaining the improvements.
Do not make your standard un-necessarily complicated. Although SAMS grades films into A, B, C, and D grades, this is not helpful for audit. You want to know what is causing the problem rather than how many grade C's you are getting.

| Legal | Deadlines | Forms | Contacts | FAQ |